Case: Culture vs. Scale: XS4ALL and KPN

*

Why did loyal customers protest a merger?

30-04-2025 467 views 0

Culture vs. Scale: XS4ALL and KPN

Two companies offering internet. One was small and personal. The other was big and efficient. Why did the smaller one disappear — and why were customers angry?

XS4ALL was one of the first internet providers in the Netherlands. It started in the early 1990s with people who cared deeply about internet freedom, privacy, and high-quality service. Many customers stayed loyal for years.

KPN is one of the biggest telecom companies in the country. It focuses on scale, cost-efficiency, and reliable nationwide service. When KPN decided to stop the XS4ALL brand, thousands of customers protested. They felt the unique spirit of XS4ALL was lost.

XS4ALL no longer exists as a separate brand.
But this real-life case still teaches us something important: even in a merger, values and identity can matter just as much as products and contracts.

In this assignment, you will compare XS4ALL and KPN and reflect on what happens when companies with very different cultures are combined.

Watch and compare: XS4ALL in action (🇳🇱)

To get a feel for how XS4ALL presented itself to customers, watch this short commercial from the past:

The video shows how the company focused on personal service and trust — even offering an extra hour of expert help during installation.
You don’t have to analyse the video in detail, but watching it will help you understand why many customers felt such a strong connection to the brand.

Public debate

The decision to shut down the XS4ALL brand caused not only customer protest, but also public debateA debate is a formal discussion where two parties present opposing viewpoints. Each side endeavors to persuade the debate moderator of the validity of their position, utilizing arguments to support th… Read more.
Internet pioneer Marleen Stikker (founder of De Digitale Stad) urged KPN to reconsider. She argued that XS4ALL stood for important values — such as openness, privacy, and digital rights.
A petition to keep the brand alive was signed by more than 37,000 people.

This was not just about internet. It was about identity, trust, and what kind of internet we want in the future.

Why this assignment matters

This case shows how internal choices affect external perception — and what you, as a future business professional, can learn from that.

Tags:

branding | economical

Share:

0

Assignments for students

What to do?

Research both companies (before the merger).
- What did XS4ALL offer that made it special?
- What does KPN focus on as a company?
Compare the two.
- What were the main differences in service, communication style, and values?
- Who was the target group for each company? (Tip: Think about people who value privacy, low prices, or personal service.)
Reflect on the merger.
- Why were customers upset when XS4ALL disappeared?
- What do you think KPN could have done to keep XS4ALL customers happy?
- What can you learn from this case about brand loyalty or the risk of losing identity as a future business professional?
  (For example: Why does brand loyalty matter? What can go wrong when identity is lost? Explain your opinionBeing able to know whether something is fact or opinion, is very important when reading news or watching an advert for example.
  • A fact is something that can be proved to be correct.
  • An op… Read more.)

Assessment Criteria

1. Description and comparison

Pass: You describe both companies clearly and explain one key difference.
Merit/Distinction: You compare them in depth, using specific examples of service, values or style.

2. Understanding of brand loyalty and identity

Pass: You show basic understanding of why customers protested.
Merit/Distinction: You reflect clearly on the importance of brand loyalty and what happens when identity is lost.

3. Quality of reflection and argument

Pass: Your opinionBeing able to know whether something is fact or opinion, is very important when reading news or watching an advert for example.
• A fact is something that can be proved to be correct.
• An op… Read more is present and supported by simple reasoning.
Merit/Distinction: Your reflection is thoughtful, well-structured and clearly motivated with business logic.

Submitting your assignment

Use the Core button in Businessbase to submit your answers.

Core assignments for students

Discover whether you master the essence of this case by completing the corresponding core assignments. If necessary, you can share your answers with your teacher or supervisor.

XS4ALL vs. KPN

* required fields

Step 1 of 2

Company

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Your name*

First Last

Your email*

Are you responding on own behalf or on behalf of a group (of students)?*

On my own behalf

On behalf of a group (of students)

Enter the first and last names of all group members

1a. What did XS4ALL offer that made it special?*

Focus on service, values, and communication style. (required)

1b. Who was the target audience of XS4ALL, and why?

Use simple business terms where possible.

2a. What does KPN focus on as a company?*

Think of scale, efficiency, or customer approach.

2b. Who is the target audience of KPN, and why?

Use simple business terms where possible.

3. What are the key differences between XS4ALL and KPN?*

Describe at least one clear difference in how they serve customers or position themselves.

4a. Reflection | Why were many customers upset when XS4ALL disappeared?*

4c. Reflection | What can you learn from this case about brand loyalty or losing identity as a future business professional?*

Explain your opinion. Use an example if possible.

4b. Reflection | What do you think KPN could have done to keep XS4ALL customers happy?

Give one or two suggestions.

3. Self Assessment | To what extent do you think you have met the requirements of this assignment?*

Tick all that apply.

Select up to 5 choices.

I described both companies clearly.

I explained the differences between them.

I used simple business terms where possible.

I reflected on brand loyalty and identity in a clear way.

I supported my opinion with examples or arguments.

Do you want to add any other information, relevant to this assignment? If so, keep it short.

Recommended by teachers

Case method | Cooperative learning

Concrete, realistic situations are individually analysed; afterwards, the resulting vision is presented and discussed in the group.
The individual’s vision is reappraised after seeking additional information. The different visions are selected and appraised.

Edvard Spaapen

Editor of content during development stage